Original Tip-Up
4.7(1,680)4.7 out of 5 stars, 1,680 reviews, on Amazon at the time this was writtenThe wooden tip-up that has been catching Great Lakes pike since the 1940s, with a sealed underwater spool that does not freeze up at fifteen below.
Frabill
Frabill · Ice Fishing
I-Float Ice Suit
4.4(810)4.4 out of 5 stars, 810 reviews, on Amazon at the time this was writtenA jacket-and-bib set with buoyant flotation foam built in, so going through the ice becomes a survivable problem instead of a fatal one.
Check price on Amazon$299— I-Float Ice SuitPrice shown was accurate on 2026-09-01. Amazon sets the live price.
What's good
- Flotation assist keeps you at the surface long enough to get your picks out and kick back onto solid ice
- Waterproof shell and taped seams handle slush and sitting on wet ice all day
- Reinforced knees and seat survive kneeling on rough ice, which is where cheap bibs fail first
What isn't
- Bulky enough to restrict movement — walking any distance in the full suit is warm work, and you will overheat on the drag out
We list the drawbacks because a recommendation with no downside is a sales pitch. If a cheaper item does the job on your water, the write-up says so.
Also worth a look
Related gear
Pro Sled
4.7(1,420)4.7 out of 5 stars, 1,420 reviews, on Amazon at the time this was writtenA rotomolded hauling sled built thick enough to drag a shelter, auger, and heater across pressure ridges without splitting.
Ice Safety Picks
4.6(2,900)4.6 out of 5 stars, 2,900 reviews, on Amazon at the time this was writtenTwo steel awls on a cord around your neck. The cheapest piece of gear that has ever saved a Great Lakes angler's life, and the most commonly skipped.
X300 Thermal Hub Shelter
4.6(1,150)4.6 out of 5 stars, 1,150 reviews, on Amazon at the time this was writtenAn insulated hub that holds heat well enough to fish Saginaw Bay in February in a sweatshirt, which is a real and specific thing this shelter does.